Skip to content
SimpleSignal

A Period of Reprimand: Assessing the U.S. House's Historic Session

This past year in the House of Representatives has gone down in the annals of history. Legislators established benchmarks for the most extended oration and the longest vote, and oversaw the most extended federal funding lapse.

Additionally, they spent significant time attempting to formally criticize one another through formal condemnation measures, the House's official mechanism for rebuke. A search of congressional records indicates at least 17 attempts since the January to condemn another lawmaker via a reprimand or a simpler statement of disapproval.

Should a reprimand resolution is approved by a simple majority of the House, the subject of the resolution must stand before the speaker's podium as the speaker informs them that they are being disciplined for their improper actions. That's as far as the practical repercussions – they retain their position and their legislative power, but potentially damaging their public image.

Though almost none of these gained approval, the flood became so pronounced that by the year's close, a group of lawmakers from both parties suggested altering the standing orders to raise the threshold for condemnation motions to pass. “Perhaps we should stop the mutual recrimination in the House?” asked one of the proposal's backers.

Here’s a look at the alleged misdeeds at the heart of the wave of reprimands:


Labeling a Figure a ‘Insult’

The initial censure attempt of the year came in February against a Democratic lawmaker. The resolution alleged the official of “inciting violence against a specific federal appointee”. It pointed to an event during a committee hearing where the lawmaker uttered a crude remark about the person in a particularly creative fashion, as well as a follow-up remark about bringing “real arms” to a political fight. The full body never considering the measure.


Yelling at the President

In the midst of a presentation to a meeting of Congress, a Democratic congressman disrupted the nation's leader, exclaiming “the people did not grant him authority” while raising a staff in the air. The House speaker directed that the congressperson escorted out. In the aftermath, a number of condemnation resolutions were introduced targeting him. A short time after, the chamber approved one of these motions, with several members of the representative's party casting yes votes alongside the other side. This remains the single reprimand to actually win approval during the year.


Resorting to Racial Stereotypes

A mere few days after the previous censure, a measure was filed aiming at a representative for remarks made about the disruptive colleague. The resolution alleged the member of using language that was “disparaging, derogatory, and racist toward another colleague”. This proposal never came up for a vote on the House floor.


Disparaging a Governor's Mobility Aid

Another reprimand effort involved claimed insulting nicknames made by a lawmaker about a state governor who is a wheelchair user. The remarks were viewed as profoundly inappropriate and prompted a censure resolution that also was not brought to a full chamber decision.


Altercation with Immigration Authorities

A number of condemnation motions were proposed against a lawmaker after she was detained and faced felony charges following an confrontation outside a government holding center. One of these motions was considered in the House, but was defeated thanks to a combination of one party and a small group of legislators from the party that introduced it. This signaled the initial instance among many instances where lawmakers crossed party lines to block a condemnation effort.


Accusations of Discrimination

A lawmaker was the subject of two censure resolutions over the summer for offensive statements made about public figures of color. The comments included derogatory nicknames and calls for removal from the country. Not one of these proposals was put up for a vote.


Disparaging a Individual's Actions

In the following period of a well-known activist's death, a condemnation motion was filed against a representative for statements that were considered “derogatory” toward the activist and those mourning him. Once again, the resolution was killed with the votes of a few of representatives from the resolution's originating party. One of those who opposed the censure stated that the right answer to “reprehensible speech” is not punishment, but “further debate”.


‘Compromising the System of a Open Election’

The wave of censures culminated late in the year when, during a key government funding vote, a representative spoke publicly to accuse that a senior member had orchestrated his retirement in a manner to guarantee a chosen replacement would be chosen to fill his seat. The resolution expressed disapproval of this behavior for “harming the integrity of a free and fair election”. This measure provoked anger but ended up being approved, with backing from most the minority party and a notable group of members from the alleging member's party.


Communicating via Text Jeffrey Epstein

As a bill to force the disclosure of official documents related to convicted criminal Jeffrey Epstein was nearing passage, reports emerged that a delegate had been in text communication with Epstein during a congressional hearing. Seeing an opportunity, political opponents lawmakers introduced a formal condemnation against the delegate. This resolution was defeated thanks to united opposition from the member's own party and the defections of a handful of lawmakers from the sponsoring party.


A Broad Spectrum of Supposed Wrongdoings

One congressman was the focus of multiple distinct reprimand efforts throughout the year, which resulted in {allegations|claims

The writer

Brendan Garcia

A digital strategist with over a decade of experience in tech innovation and content marketing, passionate about simplifying complex topics.

SimpleSignal

Type to search articles.